top of page

Don't 'meet them where they are' and leave them there

Writer: Joanne Jacobs
Joanne Jacobs
Oct 5
2 min read


"Meet students where they are," novice teachers are told. Provide different lessons for students starting at different points. But differentiation never ends, writes literacy coach Kristen McQuillan. Teachers are exhausted. Students who started behind stay behind.


Rather than ask less of some students, teachers need to provide scaffolding to get all students to the same learning goal, she writes. "That means providing extra, temporary support that helps all students access grade-level content without removing the intellectual work we ultimately want them to learn to do themselves.


"For example, a novice may need vocabulary explained, a dense sentence unpacked, the text read aloud, or a complex task broken into manageable chunks," she writes. But they shouldn't get an easier text to read or a less challenging task to do.


Scaffolding is temporary, McQuillan writes. Differentiation is forever.


The achievement gap between the strongest and the weakest students is large, and getting larger, according to an analysis released this year. In the same classroom students may be working at five or sex different grade levels.


Don't use AI to simplify texts for struggling readers, advises literacy educator Timothy Shanahan. Students should read complex tests with support, such as relevant background information. Teachers can have students read several things on the same topic with "guidance in how to make sense of the vocabulary, syntax, cohesion, and discourse structure, and in the use of helpful reading strategies." But AI use should be discouraged. Students have to do "their own reading (and thinking)."


When Michelle Brown taught seventh graders in rural Mississippi, she had a student who "spent months slumped over a 3rd-grade workbook" in her remedial English class. One day, "Johnny" wandered into her honors class, which was reading The Diary of Anne Frank. "He lit up," she writes. "He participated, asked questions, and made connections using words I’d never heard in my remedial class."


The meet-them-where-they-are system wasn’t designed to advance Johnny in reading, Brown writes in Education Week. "Struggling students are routinely pulled out of grade-level instruction and placed into interventions that often use different materials and instructional approaches." Expectations are low. Students "stay where they are" grade after grade.


"Every lesson should prepare students for the next, every grade should build on the one before it, and interventions should support rather than replace the grade-level material," writes Brown. She's now CEO of Common Lit, which helps districts find high-quality English Language Arts programs.

21 Comments

Rated 0 out of 5 stars.
No ratings yet

Add a rating
Bill
Oct 08
Rated 4 out of 5 stars.

Go back to the practice of grouping students by ability and actual knowledge (aka tracking)...


A student who does not know basic math concepts will never pass Algebra 1 or any other higher math... Period

Like
Guest
Oct 09
Replying to

"...the children of teachers, administrators, politicians, community leaders get into the college prep track with lower scores than some children of blue collar black and Hispanic families do not get in."


1) How prevalent is this? Surely you can provide us with some hard numbers. Is it the case that 50% of the desirable spots are taken by the unqualified, lower-scoring "children of teachers, administrators, politicians, [and] community leaders" or 5% or 0.5%? I would think that an expert such as you would have this information readily available.


2) The solution here is an easy one. No special treatment for anyone.

Like

Bruce William Smith
Oct 06
Rated 3 out of 5 stars.

I would not allow Ms Brown to teach her lit in my school, since her definition of "grade level" is below the international standards we use: in Secondary 7, we feature Lord of The Flies, which she relegates to 9th & 10th grades, while the students who are writing about Macbeth right now as I write this note are in Secondary 10, and Macbeth is the third complete play of Shakespeare our students have read by this grade level, in keeping with the English National Curriculum (which you've complimented, Joanne), which starts reading complete Shakespeare plays in Grade 6, while CommonLit doesn't get there until Grade 12, which means they leave every child behind.

Edited
Like
Guest
Oct 13
Replying to

"From Google AI" 😅


Providing our resident policy expert, who's never spent one minute as classroom teacher, with all the evidence it needs to make points completely irrelevant to the topic.

Like
bottom of page