The kids could 'really, really read' and do math, but adults didn't like it


Kevin Huffman was 22 when he got his first teaching job. He'd assumed that "the best ideas for kids will win," and that education leaders "will do what’s right based on the evidence." He learned otherwise, he writes on Proven Possible.
A Teach For America corps member, Huffman had no ed-school experience when he was hired as a bilingual first-grade teacher at a Houston school. His principal, Ramon Alvarez, had seen Direct Instruction working at another high-poverty school, Wesley, and decided to give it a try. Huffman was trained in "a highly structured style of teaching built on carefully sequenced, scripted lessons that break skills into small steps and rely on rapid call-and-response between teacher and students."
It worked. Soon, he partnered with another new first-grade teacher, Tomas Tapia, to use DI to teach reading in Spanish. "Before long, Tomas’ students and my students were above grade level in reading and math, in Spanish and in English."
But not everyone was happy. The principal invited visitors to tour the school. "Many expressed misgivings about direct instruction and our abandonment of 'whole language',” Huffman writes. They thought the instruction "didn’t embrace autonomy and student discovery."
They didn't seem to care that "the kids could really, really read, better than their peers in other schools," Huffman writes. "They could do math, consistently above grade level."
Season 2 of Emily Hanford’s Sold a Story podcast focuses on DI's success in the classroom and it's failure to win the hearts and minds of administrators. Huffman's former principal, trainer and mentor are interviewed.
She also reports on how DI turned Wesley, into a high-performing school under the leadership of Principal Thaddeus Lott. After Lott's retirement, DI lost its champion and was discarded. Wesley became "once again one of the lowest-performing schools in Houston," says Hanford.
"Delivering a scripted curriculum" removes "professional autonomy," critics complain, writes Huffman. "Teaching via books with giant letters and short boring sentences can seem less exciting than using an immersive and colorful big book. Embracing student discovery can seem more progressive than instructing students explicitly."
But that's not what counts, he argues. "Why do we make decisions on teaching and learning based on what adults like to do, rather than what evidence shows works for students?" For children whose parents can't teach them at home, substandard teaching at school can be disastrous.
What he learned as a 22-year-old teacher -- children's best interests don't always come come first -- led him to become CEO of Accelerate, a nonprofit that "helps schools put proven ideas into practice . . . turning evidence into better student outcomes."
Houston's test scores are rising since a state takeover in 2023. Superintendent Mike Miles introduced a series of changes, including bringing back DI at the lowest-performing schools. There no more F-rated schools. However, the new governor opposes state takeovers, and the future of Miles' New Education System is uncertain.



Comments