The anti-teaching culture: 'Can't nobody tell me nothing'

"Can't nobody tell me nothing," Lil Nas X sings in Old Town Road.

An anti-teaching culture is taking hold, writes "Bell Ringer" Holly Korbey. Instead of teachers instructing students -- or parents toilet training their toddlers, adults are supposed to motivate students to explore their interests. If that doesn't include memorizing the times tables, that's OK.
Resistance to “coercive learning,” also known as teaching, started with a small number of privileged parents, she writes. It's now much more common "both in and outside the classroom."
For a long time now, education schools have urged teachers to be a "guide on the side," rather than a "sage on the stage." When teachers are evaluated, they may lose points for talking too much, even if they're explaining a new concept. They're supposed to get students to do the talking and the thinking, ideally by "creating self-directed learning activities," says Zach Groshell, author of Just Tell Them: The Power of Explanations and Explicit Teaching. It doesn't work very well.
Emily Hanford's second season of Sold a Story has promoted Direct Instruction, a tightly structured and scripted method that's proven both effective and controversial. Even when DI is improving reading scores, it's hard to sustain, she writes." In a satirical piece feature Smug Snidely and Ima Fuller-Schlitz, Rick Hess links to all the critiques of Hanford's series.)
Should teachers do a bit of insisting, directly, that this is what kids should know, and how they should know it? Or should they spend time sparking something inside the child that causes them to want to learn?
Our culture's resistance to receiving instruction from a teacher is part of the rejection of both DI and the small d version, known as direct or explicit instruction, Korbey believes.
So is "the rabid fascination" with Alpha School, a network of private schools that claims students will learn much faster through two hours a day with AI-powered learning apps, she writes. There are no teachers. "Guides" motivate, "often with the use of prizes and incentives and cold, hard cash, she writes, but don't "kill the vibe with directives, demands and content knowledge."
The anti-teaching bias has affected schools, which are losing students to homeschoolers and unschoolers, writes Korbey. But it's also reflected in the "growing number of children who are coming to kindergarten not potty-trained, so many, in fact, that two states have created laws requiring it, with likely more to follow."
Sunday school attendance is way down. In a Christianity Today Facebook post, one commenter, suggested “Don’t call it school!,” writes Korbey. (A friend who volunteered to teach a Sunday school class was told that children should draw pictures, but needed no actual teaching.)
It might be a matter of convenience and cost, Korbey writes. "I know plenty of parents who opted their kids out of private or community-center art classes or guitar lessons, for example, because of the unlimited drawing content and basic rock chords available on YouTube."
But we lose something by our insistence on learning everything ourselves, without human interaction, she fears. We probably learn less.
Elizabeth Grace Matthew, a mother of four children under 12, fired a nice, young piano teacher who didn't want to tell her son what to do lest it interfere with his creativity and love of music. She hired an elderly Russian woman, who taught her son to play the piano.
The choice was not between "a teacher who would turn my son into a competent pianist and one who would foster his creativity," writes Matthew. It was "between a piano teacher who would turn my son into a competent pianist and one who would not." That's usually the way it works, she argues. "Learn something or learn nothing."



My exposure to tutoring centers (Kumon, Mathnasium etc) and private tutors has shown me that their model is explicit instruction by teachers who know their subject, reinforcement, practice and corrected assignments; exactly the practices that the edworld disdains. Families are willing to pay for it! Also, it’s the model for sports and the performing arts, combined with leveled groups/instruction (tracking!); both in public schools and elsewhere. No one seriously advocates for heterogeneous grouping and kids discovering their own “knowledge” or techniques in those fields.
Anything you can figure out as a kid you'll eventually figure out anyway.
The logical conclusion of this thinking is the complete elimination of education altogether.
I just read this paper by Dorothy Sayers from 1947 promoting the teaching of how to learn, how to study before rushing into teaching all the disconnected subjects. Sad we lost this. It wasn't by choice, but educator faddishness which is now a century on habit so that teachers today have no clue themselves.
AI has surpassed the student, and professor, in knowledge of a subject, if only students were taught how to assess, dissect and meld knowledge to gain insight not yet recorded.
Thanks for sharing this, Joanne! Would love to hear what people think, this has been on my mind for a while.
If unteaching doesn't work, hire some more "student support" personnel without any actual content knowledge or practical experience. After all, nothing creates more success than people who make and put up posters that say "Success!" on them.
Soon, Professor Harold Hill can also chair the math, physics, English, history, and sociology departments in addition to music. He can also be the dean of student success and perhaps the provost too.
It's not turtles all the way down--it's flim-flam all the way down.