To close Berkeley's huge math gap, follow the cognitive science

Berkeley's public schools say they're devoted to equity, but the math achievement gap between white and black students is enormous, write a trio of parents on Berkeleyside. Twenty-three percent of black students score as proficient, compared to 81 percent of white students.

The school district should follow the cognitive science by adopting coherent curriculum and direct instruction, write Ivi Kolasi, Halyna Sendoun, Lindsay Nofelt and Samantha Cooper, members of Learning for Berkeley. Universal screening should be used to identify students who need extra help.
In addition, middle and high schools should offer advanced math pathways for the 49 percent of students who meet math standards, they write. Berkeley Unified "has effectively outsourced math achievement to the private market. Families with means purchase private tutors, learning academies, and outside accredited courses," while those who can't afford it are left behind. "Math has become a pay-to-play commodity."
Their coalition has published A Path to Math Equity: A Toolkit for K-12 Families.
Education researchers surveyed by the New York Times evaluated 30 potential solutions to fix American schools, they write. "The findings were unambiguous: high-quality, research-backed curriculum, ample practice, and targeted instructional intervention rank among the most effective investments a district can make."
For all the talk about educational equity, Berkeley Unified didn't adopt a literacy curriculum grounded in the Science of Reading until it was pushed by a 2017 lawsuit, they write. "Teachers now explicitly teach phonics, how letters map to sounds, and morphology, how word parts build meaning. Children no longer have to guess their way to reading."
But math students are still guessing. "Inquiry-based instruction asks students to discover concepts with little direct teaching," they write. "For novice learners, this approach induces cognitive overload, ensuring foundational skills never stick; for advanced learners, it wastes time forcing them to 'rediscover' concepts that direct, explicit instruction could teach in minutes."
"Decades of research show that explicit instruction, with clear explanations, worked examples, and enough practice, builds fluency," which "frees students to take on harder problems," they argue. "A struggling student needs it to catch up. An advanced student needs it to accelerate on solid ground."
In Education Week, Sarah Schwartz writes about schools trying to move from the "science of reading" to research-based math instruction. Eighteen states have passed laws that call for "a focus on foundational skills in grades K-5, requirements for universal screening and targeted intervention for struggling students, and mandates for data-based decision-making and explicit, systematic instruction," according to a Center on Reinventing Public Education analysis. Implementation is challenging.
A newly passed California law will require screening K-2 students for math difficulties, starting in 2028. It's critical to screen for math fact fluency, write David Margulies and Rahim Nathwani on EdSource. They quote Tom Loveless: “Math facts are to math as phonics is to reading.”



Comments