top of page

Detention works -- for go-with-the-flow students

Writer: Joanne Jacobs
Joanne Jacobs
Oct 7
3 min read

The age-old punishment of after-school detention is out of fashion, writes David Didau on Learning Spy. Detentions are not the answer, say critics, because punitive sanctions “don’t address the underlying cause.”


Detentions don't always work for misbehaving student, he argues. They just keep on acting up. But enforcing sanctions for misbehavior works for the vast majority of students, he argues.. And they work for teachers.


It could be worse. U.S. students aren't torching their schools. Photo: Jean-Francois Badias/AP
It could be worse. U.S. students aren't torching their schools. Photo: Jean-Francois Badias/AP

Social and cultural norms are powerful, writes Didau. If rules are enforced, most students will go along. If enforcement is inconsistent, students get the message that the rules don't really matter.


A 2002 study tracked disciplinary referrals for students from low-income families at a British school, he writes. One group that received detentions in the fall had shaped up by the end of the year, receiving no more referrals than those never sanctioned by the spring. A second group of students, who'd started out no worse than the first group, behaved worse.


Apparently, detentions work for some students, but not hard-core rule breakers, Didau concludes. Using this group "to judge whether detention deters students in general is like evaluating the effectiveness of speed cameras by only interviewing drivers who’ve been caught speeding."


There's plenty of evidence that seeing offenders sanctioned affects perceptions about what's acceptable, Didau writes. Observers decide: "That’s not what we do round here."


When people see one norm violated, they're more likely to violate other norms, concludes a 2008 paper, The Spreading of Disorder. In one experiment, researchers "attached advertising flyers to parked bicycles. When the surrounding area was clean, people took the flyer with them rather than dropping it on the ground. But when the walls were covered in graffiti, despite signs explicitly prohibiting it, substantially more people littered."


When "students perceive rules to be clear, discipline to be fair and adults to enforce expectations consistently," they behave better.


Detentions work for go-with-the-flow students, writes Didau. And they enable schools to create a safe, respectful climate that makes learning possible.


If suspensions and expulsions rise, that doesn't mean students are behaving worse, writes Tom Bennett, a behavior consultant for English schools. It could mean that the system is working. (If arrests for burglaries rise, he writes, "it could just mean that police were getting better at catching burglars.")


Many expulsions are for very dangerous behavior, such as bringing a weapon to school, he writes. Keeping these students on campus "leads to chaotic and unsafe classrooms where no one benefits -- least of all the most vulnerable."


"Persistent disorder harms academic achievement, disrupts teachers’ ability to teach, and hurts students who depend on schools as a pathway to upward mobility," writes Neetu Arnold. States should enact "a strong teachers’ bill of rights" to "clarify teachers’ authority to remove students."


Teachers say they get "little to no support from administrators when dealing with fights, consistent disruptive behavior, and even threats," she writes. "A common scenario is that a teacher will send a disruptive student to the principal’s office, only for that student to return quickly to class, undermining the teacher’s authority."


Teachers are told to build relationships, look for "root causes" and "unmet needs" and use positive reinforcement. Many are fed up with the chaos. They quit the classroom or move to a more orderly school, and the school hires an inexperienced teacher who doesn't have better choices.

17 Comments

Rated 0 out of 5 stars.
No ratings yet

Add a rating
Guest
Oct 09

Having now seen the arrest video (and read the transcript) of the 6-year-old who shot his teacher--I'm guessing that there is at least one for whom detention won't be much of a deterrent.


I think that my generation was considerably more worried about parental consequences than the detention itself.

Like

Bill
Oct 08
Rated 5 out of 5 stars.

Students who engaged in bad behavior despite required parent conferences were eventually sent to opportunity school for middle and high school students...


These schools were heavy on study, heavy on security and police and very few privileges compared to a regular middle or high school...


You went to class, went to lunch and went home.. That was a typical day for the worse students.. Students who did not want to be in high school could legally dropout at age 16 so most of them left at the end of 10th grade which made teachers and administrators very happy

Like
Guest
Oct 09
Replying to

The likelihood of a real teachers' union lobbyist advocating completely voluntary high school enrollment is roughly equal to that of a snowball remaining intact while sitting in direct sunlight on a driveway in Dallas in July. Try again.


Like

Malcolm Kirkpatrick
Oct 08
Rated 4 out of 5 stars.

Classroom chaos is the #1 reason that teachers give when researchers ask ex-teachers why they left the system. Another term for it is "lack of support from admin".

Freedom of association and freedom of contract in a tax-subsidized, parent-directed competitive market in education services would greatly enhance the classroom environment. Principals should pick their staff. Parents should decide how their children will spend the time between birth and age 18.

Aside: Search Youtube: Katharine Birbalsingh. You should follow her.

Like

Suzanne
Oct 07
Rated 5 out of 5 stars.

Common sense. It's almost unbelievable--except we see it again and again in public life--that the obvious even needs to be said: that disruptive students should be disciplined and removed, to allow for the education of those who are willing to participate in it.

Like
Guest
Oct 09
Replying to

You keep using this term "strict discipline," but what is that supposed to mean? Surely what any thinking person wants is discipline adequate to maintain a conducive learning environment, not "strict" for the sake of strict.


As far as I can tell, all the local public schools share a set of behavioral expectations across the board for schools at the same grade levels; they're laid out in a handbook. This is also certainly the case for all the parochial schools here. If anything, there is less tolerance of disruptive behavior at the schools with more white and Asian students. Are you suggesting that these students be penalized for behaving too well? A moral and educated citizen would want the benefits…

Like
bottom of page