top of page
  • Writer's pictureJoanne Jacobs

Tell parents truth: Enough with the happy talk


Tell parents the unpleasant truth about learning loss, writes Andrew Rotherham in a story on the state NAEP scores in the The 74. "The disaster and inequity of pandemic policies is now in clear focus," he writes. Despite a few outliers -- Department of Defense and Catholic schools -- "it’s an across-the-board disaster for the United States."


"Students already furthest from success in school were most impacted," he writes. "Thirty-eight percent of eighth-graders are at a level in mathematics that leaves them functionally unprepared to fend for themselves in the world, let alone pursue success in various college and career opportunities."

In Virginia, where many schools were closed for in-person instruction longer than elsewhere, scores fell sharply, writes Rotherham, who serves on the state board of education.

Yet many parents are confused about what's happened to reading and math achievement, he writes.

Some professional development focuses on helping teachers distract attention from objective measures of reading and numeracy. Leading newspapers have misled readers about whether any of this even matters. States like New York and California have dragged their feet on releasing test score data, while in other places, school officials are minimizing the importance of standardized exams.
The overall fecklessness, irresponsibility and almost total attention to politics and public relations rather than kids surprises even cynical observers of the sector.

"Learning loss" became "unfinished learning," as though students were bound to rebound quickly.

"State leaders must communicate directly with parents about the data — what it means and what families should expect as a remedy," Rotherham writes. "Obviously, states and school districts should provide support to students and families such as tutoring, direct grants to parents, expanded choice options, longer school days and a longer school year for students." But the first step is honesty.

"Happy talk" is the besetting sin of education. Remember all the talk about how "resilient" kids are? Now we're about to hear that schools should focus on social and emotional learning -- or anything else that can't be measured -- rather than boring old math. Instead of reading -- it's so oppressive -- kids can learn to watch TikTok videos.

2,140 views8 comments

8 Comments


Guest
Oct 27, 2022

Well, here we are howling for yet another "Silver Bullet," this time vouchers.


If only vouchers were universally available everything would be taken care of ! It's the home, not the school, not a voucher to free you to think, well I don't have to worry about that anymore.


Vietnamese boat people arrived here, parents usually with no education to speak of, no English, no money, kids forced to go to schools that were "failing" the students... Parents had to take the most menial jobs but five hence the children thereof scored 58% in English and a whopping 93% in math.


After dinner the table would be cleared for homework, parents sitting with their children, not that they could hel…


Like

Guest
Oct 27, 2022

b

Like

Guest
Oct 26, 2022

The public education industry really does not care about any of this beyond the fact that it reflects badly on them, harming their political clout. This is why they want to get rid of standardized testing.

Like

Guest
Oct 26, 2022

"Mockingbird" by Walter Tevis outlines where these policies will lead, IMO.

Like

Guest
Oct 26, 2022

Every public-school teacher, and every public-school administrator, is an enemy of the United States, an enemy of traditional families, and most of all, an enemy of the children they are supposed to be serving.


Vouchers, so that money follows the students, for private schools and home schooling.

Like
Guest
Oct 26, 2022
Replying to

Moving the college application process to kindergarten will not solve very much.

Like
bottom of page