top of page

We can read hard things -- if we put away the phones and try

  • Writer: Joanne Jacobs
    Joanne Jacobs
  • Jul 24
  • 2 min read

People are reading (or, at least, buying) The Odyssey, thanks to Christopher Nolan's blockbuster movie. They're arguing about whether the many-sided Odysseus should be seen as a heroic adventurer, a sword-shocked vet, a crafty killer or a dozen other interpretations. Emily Wilson's modern translation has sold one million copies, and three other translations are on the top 10 list.


Young Americans can learn to read complex, challenging books, writes Natalie Wexler. Those who do will have an advantage over AI's cognitive cripples.


Rose Horowitch's “end of reading" story in The Atlantic suggests short-form videos are returning us to

"the kind of oral culture that produced Homeric epic poems," Wexler writes. "Those who absorb information through listening rather than reading respond best to epithets, repetition, and descriptions of violence, and they’re not bothered by self-contradiction because they can’t remember what the speaker said before."


The future may belong to the readers and thinkers, Wexler suggests. "AI firms are hiring philosophy majors, paying them big bucks to ponder questions of consciousness."


“The people who are reading hard books and are still writing have built these brain circuits, and they’re comfortable with cognitive strain,” computer science professor Cal Newport told the New York Times. “These are the people with real value if everyone else has fried their brains.”

Students need to be taught to read and understand whole books, not just excerpts, Wexler argues.

"Literacy curricula that incorporate whole books — and build the knowledge that actually fuels reading comprehension—are gaining ground."


Justin McDaniels, a religious studies professor at Penn, teaches an intensive reading course called “Existential Despair." Once a week, students hand over their phones at 5 pm, read the assigned book, and then discuss it. Class ends at midnight. Of 400 who applied -- business, engineering and nursing students, not just humanities majors -- only 41 got in.


Students read 17 books in one semester, reports Dave Zeitlin in The Pennsylvania Gazette. "I really hadn’t sat down and read a book for four years,” said Ryan Ghose, a marketing major. It's been a "life-changing experience."


I think I first read The Iliad and The Odyssey -- surely excerpts -- in Junior Great Books when I was in middle school. There were bits of the latter in a book I owned, The World's Great Myths and Legends. (As a monotheist, I was shocked by the Greek, Roman and Norse gods. They were just powerful and often badly behaved people!) We read Edith Hamilton's Mythology in seventh grade for school. Then more Iliad and Odyssey in 12th-grade Great Books, using Richard Lattimore's translation.


I disliked Achilles, the big booby. Sulking in your tent when your country is at war! But Odysseus was sneaky. I liked him.

3 Comments

Rated 0 out of 5 stars.
No ratings yet

Add a rating
Guest
Jul 26
Rated 4 out of 5 stars.

Alex Tokarev, Kristin Tokarev, "School Choice Is the Market Key to Education Success", Acton blog.

"What works?" is an empirical question, to which a competitive market in education services will supply more valid and reliable answers than will Divine (bureaucratic) Inspiration.


Puzzles are nice, but people vary in their tolerance for frustration and it's arrogant for strangers to decide the appropriate level of frustration to impose on other people's children.


I like the fable of the boy who received from his father a calf and instructions to care for the calf and to carry it one lap around the track every day. As the calf brew the young man grew stronger.

I taught Secondary Math. It was my aspiration that…

Like

Guest
Jul 24
Rated 5 out of 5 stars.

I thought Homer made Odysseus look like a jerk in the Iliad. Also, I noted that he used the expression "God Like Odysseus" and thought that phrase might have been some sort of Greek religion skeptic satire. Of course, as you point out, Odysseus's character is more worked out in the Odyssey. Interesting, another difference between these books is in their treatment of the afterlife. In the Iliad, it is just dark and cold. In the Odyssey, the afterlife is both personal and bad. In Virgil this gets better.

Like

Bill
Jul 24
Rated 5 out of 5 stars.

For those of us in the late 70's and early 80's who went to high school and took either American or European or World Literature, you definitely got a LOT to read and write or type reports on (and yes, cliff's notes were available), but that didn't help you if you got called on in class to explain a section and you hadn't read it (LOLZ)

Like
bottom of page