top of page
  • Writer's pictureJoanne Jacobs

The kids can't write


Photo: Jan Vašek/Pixabay

Students are encouraged to express themselves, writes Elizabeth Grace Matthew, who's taught writing at several universities, on The Hill. But most are unable to "reliably construct grammatical sentences" or write at what used to be the fifth-grade level.


"Most of my students did not know basic grammar and punctuation because they were never drilled and tested on these concepts," she writes.

My Italian-American grandmother, by contrast, who attended Philadelphia public schools in the 1930s and had parents who spoke broken English and no books in her home, could reliably capitalize and punctuate basic sentences. This would put her in the top 10 percent of the hundreds of students I taught over the years, at least half of whom had college-educated parents.

Her grandmother was taught in school to meet the same standards as children from more privileged families.


(My grandmother, who was born in what's now Ukraine, left school after eighth grade with good reading and writing skills.)


"Mastery precedes" creativity, writes Matthews. "As any top-tier jazz musician can explain, to break rules productively, you must first know the rules and how to follow them."


But many of her college students hadn't mastered syntax, grammar and punctuation. Furthermore, their writing assignments "focused on emotional self-expression, not rational argumentation." Most "were not only poor writers but also underdeveloped thinkers."


New AI technology will be able to fix the errors in students' writing. Some could use AI as a writing coach -- not a way to cheat. What are the odds it will

361 views20 comments

Recent Posts

See All

20 Comments


Guest
Sep 11, 2023

We AMZSparks specialise in helping businesses like yours reach their full potential. Whether you’re looking to increase your sales, streamline your operations, or expand your reach, we got you covered. From precise Amazon Catalog Management to expert Amazon Product Sourcing, we've got you covered. Boost visibility and sales with meticulous Amazon Keyword Research and compelling Amazon Listing Optimization. Launch and rank your products with precision using our proven strategies. Dominate the marketplace with our results-driven Amazon PPC Management and trust us with seamless Amazon Account Management. Expand your brand reach with our strategic Brand Expanding Management services. Experience unparalleled success on Amazon with our comprehensive solutions tailored for your business.


Contact us today at : info@amzsparks.com


Like

Guest
Sep 03, 2023

Scholarace is a leading source of guidance and information on learning and educational prospects for students wishing to study abroad or looking for a scholarship. We offer a comprehensive database of schools and scholarships, as well as tips and advice on every step of the study abroad process. We also Guide students looking for some tips to ace that essay writing task, an undergraduate college student wanting to score an A grade in his/her research study or a postgraduate student wishing for some effective writing tips on their PhD thesis task, we’re confident that Scholarace will be of great help to you.

we encourage you to visit our website Scholarace.com or Contact us at: info@scholarace.com


Like

Guest
Jan 10, 2023

To make students writing error My Assignment help is here to help them. My Assignment help is the leading assignment help service in Australia that has been successfully serving the students of Australia for almost ten years. Ph.D. Qualified online assignment help experts cover a wide range of subjects for the students of top colleges and universities, and we have become a trusted partner in academic support.

Like

Steve Sherman
Steve Sherman
Dec 23, 2022

" Most "were not only poor writers but also underdeveloped thinkers."

the latter causes the former not the other way around

Like
Guest
Jan 03, 2023
Replying to

No, I disagree. If you have never been taught phonixs, vocabulary, spelling, grammar, or punctuation, you can't possibly form a devoiped thought. You're spending too much time on these basic building blocks to read or write fluently. Without being able to engage a sentence, you can't engage a paragraph. Without a paragraph, no essays.


Much like a student who can't do arithmetic is lost in a complicated word problem that requires facility with fractions and decimals, a student can't build up to a meaningful thesis without the basic structure and practice of the English language.

Like

Guest
Dec 15, 2022

Want to see what happens when English and writing are not held in high regard as a subject to master?


I see more news headlines with bad spelling or poor grammar today than I ever did when I delivered newspapers as a teenager on my bicycle (of course, you wouldn't get hired as a writer or proofreader without actually knowing how to do those things back then either).


Sigh

R

Like
bottom of page