top of page

Philosophy majors can get loans, but maybe not beauty-school students

Writer: Joanne Jacobs
Joanne Jacobs
Oct 6
2 min read

“Degrees for social work, art, religious studies, teaching aides, and music will be hit the hardest” by the Trump administration's new limits on high-risk student loans, warns The New Republic.


Not so, responds Matthew Yglesias. Cosmetology and culinary studies certificates at for-profit colleges will be hardest hit. Undergraduate programs whose graduates earn less than someone with only a high school diploma will be denied federal loans. In addition, people won't be able to take out federal loans they'll never repay for a master's program whose graduates earn no more than people with a bachelor's degree.


It's a very low bar, he writes. "Every liberal arts program from every even remotely selective college easily clears this bar." That includes his major, philosophy, which leads to higher earnings than the average bachelor's degree.


Trump's rule replaces a Biden administration rule, which modified the Obama administration's "gainful employment" rule, writes Yglesias. More programs -- not just for-profit colleges -- have to prove they raise earnings.


"The vast majority of failing programs continue to be undergrad certificates or associate degree programs like cosmetology," he writes. However, some master's programs in religious studies, mental health counseling and studio art at nonprofit universities will not meet the economic benefit test. "I suppose your mileage may vary as to whether it’s good for traditional nonprofit universities to run low-value master’s degree programs as a cash cow, but I think it’s pretty bad."


People can still get master's degrees in religious studies or studio art, of course, but not on the taxpayers' dime.


The loan limits "protect students from terrible colleges and crippling debt," writes AEI's Preston Cooper. Only about five percent of college students will be affected with half of those seeking short-term certificates in for-profit colleges.


"Almost all bachelor’s degree programs clear the bar easily," writes Cooper. Ninety-two percent of fine arts programs will clear the bar. There's no need to worry about teacher-training programs. Teachers earn more than high school graduates.



"The country’s most prestigious journalism school also announced a new online, part-time degree," reports Sarah Scire. Masters of science programs in Journalism and Data Journalism will continue.


Changing visa policies have "caused a sharp drop in international applications" to the MA program, Aditya Soni and Edmund Lee report for Reuters. "The dynamics of visas and all those other kinds of things were part of the consideration," ​Cobb told Reuters. About half of MA students come from overseas.

4 Comments

Rated 0 out of 5 stars.
No ratings yet

Add a rating
Momof4
Oct 6

My late FIL was the principal of a small-city tech HS for many years. Among others, his school offered programs in cosmetology, auto mechanics, carpentry, tool & die, sheet metal and licensed practical nursing (LPN); all of which produced graduates that employers were eager to hire. The academic HS, like my small-town HS, had a highly-respected secretarial program. In fact, the best secretary my late husband ever had (decades later) was a recent graduate of that high school. I would love to see more of that level of voc ed offerings. I don’t know much about it, but there is a voc ed HS in my area. I don’t know much about it, but do know that there’s a carpentry…

Like

Guest
Oct 6

We have long had a basically useless Masters degree that changes its name every few years (think something like "Leadership"). I wonder how ED will keep up with re-naming and re-branding of basically the same old twaddle.

Like
Guest
Oct 6
Replying to

Our district doesn't give credit for stuff like our "Leadership" degrees. It has to be a Masters in Education or an MA/MS in a content area. Several contracts ago, there was a requirement that Masters degrees in Education had to have something explicitly to do with content or instruction. I think this was in response to some very lightweight degrees the local public directional was peddling.

Like
bottom of page