top of page

Parents say: Bring back pencil and paper

  • Writer: Joanne Jacobs
    Joanne Jacobs
  • Feb 18
  • 2 min read


A small but growing number of parents are opting their children out of using school-issued Chromebooks and IPads, writes Tyler Kingkade for NBC News. They cite "concerns about distractions and access to inappropriate content."


Parents "point to research showing that students who used computers at school performed worse academically and that information is better retained when read on paper," he writes. They don't believe using today's devices will prepare students to use future technology.


“I want them to be taught through humans,” said Julie Frumin, who lives in a Los Angeles suburb. “I want the teachers to teach my kids — I think they know best.”


After some resistance, the school agreed. Her children get print-outs of assignments, writes Kingkade. " Instead of playing games on their laptops during free time, they read books."


"Computers are now ubiquitous in K-12 education," he writes. Nearly 9 in 10 public schools provide a device for each middle and high school student, as do more than 4 in 5 elementary schools.


Students spend too much time on screens, says David Stein, a math teacher in Montgomery County, Maryland. It's time to think what's essential and what isn't.


The local PTA wants the district to create a way for parents to request "non-screen alternatives" for their children.


Kaitlan Finn started a parent group in her suburban Chicago school district that's lobbying to let students keep Chromebooks at school rather than take them home, she told Kingkade. “Screen use feels like tobacco use used to be,” Finn said. “You know, kids used to have rooms they could smoke in at school before they realized how bad it was years ago. I feel like my kids are being forced to smoke cigarettes during the school day, but then they’re also sending a pack of cigarettes home with them too.”


Fresno Unified wants elementary students to bring their school-issued laptops back to the classroom, reports Lasherica Thornton for EdSource.


It's partly a financial decision: It costs too much to keep replacing and repairing the devices. In addition, teachers and parents said students weren't using the laptops to complete assignments at home.


Schools in Sweden are limiting screen time and bringing back books -- physical books. In Britain, the Conservatives propose letting students opt out of screen-based homework.

4 Comments

Rated 0 out of 5 stars.
No ratings yet

Add a rating
Jack Clomps
Feb 20

"Ed tech" is a great money-maker for companies who know how to dazzle school boards with a lot of fancy looking/sounding material that is often thin gruel when it comes to actual content. A lot of the ed tech in math is also a convenient fix for the lack of high-quality math teachers in too many districts.

If a teacher can figure out how to implement a bell-to-bell regimen of scripted lessons including screen time, he or she can avoid grading, avoid having to know the specific step where a student erred, and avoid creating rich-in-content lessons on challenging topics that require scaffolded instruction and repetition.

I challenge any qualified and experienced algebra teacher to spend time going through the…

Like

Suzanne
Feb 19
Rated 5 out of 5 stars.

Smart parents!

Wouldn't we all admit that 'screens are for skimming content' whereas books (assuming that the schools will ask students to read 'real' and challenging works of literature!) are for reading (and understanding).

Students may need to be told, at first, that "reading" is not the same as flicking your eyes over the words that appear; but rather involves reading and processing and remembering the content so deeply that you can discuss it competently.

Especially with the Common Core push towards informational texts, students have probably gathered that they're meant to read to discover discrete facts. If they get to read actual literature, there will be more to read for (implications, suggestions, framing), and more to discuss.

Yes, go…

Like

Guest
Feb 19

Clifford Stoll made the case that computes don’t belong in the schools in High Tech Heretic in 1999. He wasn’t wrong

Like

Guest
Feb 18

We've been getting this too at my high school. So we have about 1/3 of the kids that don't have a Chromebook because they refuse to buy a new one after lost or stolen, and 2/3 who have working Chromebooks. period so what we've done is we go ahead and print off stuff for the kids without chromebooks but we still require them to submit all work at the same time period time limit is not changed.

Like
bottom of page