Common Core standards are making math education even worse, writes Marina Ratner, a Berkeley math professor emerita, in the *Wall Street Journal*.

As a sixth grader at a Berkeley public school, her grandson was required to “draw pictures of everything,” she writes.

. . . of 6 divided by 8, of 4 divided by 2/7, of 0.8 x 0.4, and so forth. In doing so, the teacher followed the instructions: “Interpret and compute quotients of fractions, and solve word problems involving division of fractions by fractions, e.g., by using visual fraction models and equations to represent the problem. For example, create a story context for 2/3 divided by 3/4 and use a visual fraction model to show the quotient . . .”

Who would draw a picture to divide 2/3 by 3/4?

This requirement of visual models and creating stories is all over the Common Core. The students were constantly told to draw models to answer trivial questions, such as finding 20% of 80 or finding the time for a car to drive 10 miles if it drives 4 miles in 10 minutes, or finding the number of benches one can make from 48 feet of wood if each bench requires 6 feet. A student who gives the correct answer right away (as one should) and doesn’t draw anything loses points.

Core math requires “convoluted and meaningless manipulations of simple concepts,” Ratner writes.

. . . the Common Core’s “deeper” and “more rigorous” standards mean replacing math with some kind of illustrative counting saturated with pictures, diagrams and elaborate word problems. Simple concepts are made artificially intricate and complex with the pretense of being deeper—while the actual content taught was primitive.

Common Core’s math standards are lower than the standards of high-achieving countries and lower than California’s old standards, Ratner concludes. “They are lower in the total scope of learned material, in the depth and rigor of the treatment of mathematical subjects, and in the delayed and often inconsistent and incoherent introductions of mathematical concepts and skills.”

Ratner is wrong on the facts, responds Bill McCallum, a math professor who helped write the standards. Here’s his post on drawings in the Common Core.

## Recent Comments