The Common Core makes simple math more complicated in order to teach understanding, writes Libby Nelson on Vox.
In the past, “students had this sense that math was some kind of magical black box,” says Dan Meyer, a former high school math teacher studying math education at Stanford University. “That wasn’t good enough.”
Students will learn different ways to multiply, divide, add, and subtract so they can see why the standard method works, writes Nelson. “They can play with them in fun, flexible ways,” says Meyer, who blogs at Dy/Dan.
Using a number line for subtraction lets students visualize the “distance” between two numbers. A father’s complaint about a confusing number line problem went viral on the Internet. Nelson provides a clearer version.
Students put the two numbers at opposite ends of the number line.
It’s 4 steps from 316 to 320, 100 steps from 320 to 420, 7 steps from 420 to 427.
Then they add the steps together: 4 + 100 + 7 = a distance of 111. LearnZillion, a company that creates lesson plans for teaching to the Common Core standards, has a 5-minute video explaining this technique.
“Students should be able to understand any of these approaches,” said Morgan Polikoff, an assistant professor of education at the University of Southern California who is studying how the Common Core is implemented in the classroom. “It doesn’t mandate that they necessarily do one or the other.”
“A key question is whether elementary school teachers can learn to teach the conceptual side of math effectively,” writes Nelson.
If not, number lines and area models will just become another recipe, steps to memorize in order to get an answer, Polikoff says.
This is a real risk: Many elementary teachers are strong on reading and weak in math (and science). Perhaps we need math/science specialists in elementary school who understand their subject deeply and can teach kids to understand too.