Homeschooling family won’t be deported

A family who fled Germany to homeschool their children won’t be deported, despite the U.S. Supreme Court’s decision not to hear their asylum appeal, reports Reason‘s Hit & Run blog. learnin about america

A Homeland Security official told the Romeikes’ attorneys they’d been granted “indefinite deferred status,” according to the Homeschool Legal Defense Association.

Germany bans homeschooling under a Nazi-era law. Parents are threatened with huge fines and loss of custody of their children. The Romeikes, who are devout Christians, fled to the U.S. and received asylum in 2010. Then the Department of Justice got the asylum ruling reversed, arguing that the German ban doesn’t constitute religious persecution.

By first opposing asylum and then granting “indefinite deferral,” the Obama administration has enforced  “the idea that, in immigration as in other policy domains, the rule of men trumps the rule of law,” writes Ed Krayewski.

About Joanne


  1. Ruth Joy says:

    You’ve got to wonder why the feds used so many resources to get the original ruling reversed. which is how it got to the Supreme Court in the first place.

    • SC Math Teacher says:

      Pandering to their (read: Obama’s) base?

      Then allowing them to stay just to show how magnanimous they are, even though they technically should be deported. Obama and his agencies can just make up the law as circumstances dictate.

      • SC Math Teacher says:

        To clarify: When I stated “they technically should be deported”, I was referring to the Supreme Court’s decision not to hear the case and that would normally have inevitably followed. I do not support that, nor do I support the administration having taken the case to that point.