An Idaho teacher let fourth-graders scribble with markers on the faces of classmates who didn’t meet reading goals, reports the Times-News.
The Declo teacher had let the class pick a reward for those who met Accelerated Reader goals. Instead, the class picked a punishment — no recess or a marked face — for those who fell short.
When Cindy Hurst’s 10-year-old son arrived home from school Nov. 5, his entire face, hairline to chin, was scribbled on in red marker — including his eyelids. He also had green, red and purple scribble marks over the red, and his face was scratched by a marker that had a rough edge.
“He was humiliated, he hung his head and wanted to go wash his face,” said Hurst. “He knows he’s a slow reader. Now he thinks he should be punished for it.”
Nine of 21 students didn’t meet their goals. Three chose to go without recess and six chose to have their faces marked.
Karla Christensen, whose daughter met her reading goal, defended teacher Summer Larsen.
Christensen said if her daughter had come home with similar marks, she would have felt it was a reflection on her own parenting for not making sure her daughter reached her goal.
“I think (Larsen)is just a very creative teacher who was trying to do something to motivate the students and it went astray,” Christensen said.
LeRoy Robinson, a grandfather of two of the marked-up students, said Larsen made a “poor choice and basically, it was bullying.” Children had to wear the marker all day and then found it wouldn’t wash off, he said.
The teacher missed several days of school after the incident, but it’s not clear whether she was suspended. A complaint has been filed with the professional ethics board.