More ‘A’ students are being placed in remedial college classes. It’s not grade inflation, says a researcher.

Carnegie’s math pathways for remedial students are showing signs of success. Students learn statistics or “quantitative reasoning.”

Thinking and Linking by Joanne Jacobs

May 4, 2012 by Joanne

More ‘A’ students are being placed in remedial college classes. It’s not grade inflation, says a researcher.

Carnegie’s math pathways for remedial students are showing signs of success. Students learn statistics or “quantitative reasoning.”

Filed Under: College, Education Tagged With: A students, Carnegie, grade inflation, math, remediation, statistics

- Joanne on Chinese kids risk death to get to school
- John Johns on Chinese kids risk death to get to school
- Malcolm Kirkpatrick on Ivy League’s Asian problem
- Richard Aubreyr on Ivy League’s Asian problem
- Jim on Ivy League’s Asian problem

- Ahead of the Heard
- Chalkbeat NY
- Chalkboard
- Citizen Ed
- Curriculum Matters
- Diane Ravitch
- Doug Lemov's Field Notes
- Dropout Nation
- EdCentral
- EdSource Today
- Educated Reporter
- Education Gadfly
- Education News
- Education Next
- Education Post
- Education Reform Now
- Edutopia Blog
- Eduwonk
- Edvocate
- EIA Intercepts
- Equity Line
- FIRE’s Torch
- Head in the Sand
- Hechinger Report
- InformED
- Inside School Research
- Jay P. Greene
- Kitchen Table Math
- Larry Cuban
- Minding the Campus
- Out in Left Field
- Politics K-12
- Pundicity
- Put Kids First
- Real Clear Education
- redefinEd
- Shanker Blog
- Sherman Dorn
- Teacher Beat
- This Week in Education
- Top Performers

Copyright © 2016 · Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in

Her logic is that it’s not grade inflation because the percentage of kids graduating from HS with an A average has not increased.

She doesn’t seem to consider the possibility that an A student today has mastered less material than an A student of 20 years ago….

There are also studies by the ACT folks …

http://www.act.org/research/policymakers/pdf/issues.pdf

They have a much larger statistical universe to draw upon than a “large urban community college system”; their statistical power should be much higher.

… or that the demographics of students today isn’t what it was 20 years ago.

Hmm.. looking at the chart, a student with a 3.5 GPA today is the equivelant of a mid-B student of yesteryear— so, inflation, but, in the old days B students didn’t get remediation either….

Isn’t it worth knowing what course level the As were in?

It’s not grade inflation, says a researcher.That’s actually true. It’s not really grade inflation so much as a school full of illiterates, so the least illiterate just have As.

Well, if it isn’t grade inflation, then what could it be. A student who is actually earning A’s in all their core subjects and gets an ACT composite score of say 18-23 isn’t actually earning their grades. A student who actually knows the material should get an ACT of at least 28 or better in the subject matter in question.

I’d look at the difference between GPA and ACT/SAT score, if the student is being placed in remediation, due to the fact that while a GPA can be inflated, the ACT/SAT score cannot be (unless the student has someone else take the test for them).

Geez