Tight goals, loose means

Ann Bailey-Lipsett, an elementary teacher who blogs at Organized Chaos, was asked to be one of the teacher bloggers at Education Sector’s Finding the Link: Teacher Evaluation and Professional Development conference. She learned that the Education Department’s mantra is: Tight on goals, loose on means.

With first graders this process usually starts out in a few different ways.

The “structure-seekers” ask a lot of questions like “Where do I put my pencil?” “What is the right answer?” and “Do you want us to use blue paper or light blue paper?” while the “oh good, freedom! Let’s see what we can do/get away with” group gets busy making something happen. Not necessarily the right thing, mind you, but paper gets cut, glue bottles are out, excited chatter starts. Then another group, of course, the “run and hiders” manage to sneak into the classroom bathroom, or into the classroom library . . .  All the while, the “I have the right answer” group of children is walking around the room telling everyone else what to do with utmost confidence. And of course, because they are 6 and 7, they end up crying, stamping their feet, and swearing that they are not Susie/Jamie/Max’s friend because Susie/Jamie/Max wont listen to their idea.

It’s sort of like the reactions to Race to the Top and the attempt to reauthorize the Elementary and Secondary Education Act (“The act formally known as NCLB”).

Some states immediately got busy applying for RttT grants, while others refused to participate in the process. Some are not acknowledging that any change is occurring and will not until they’ve seen progress from other states, while some, who comfortably followed NCLB, are still waiting for specific instructions. Even in the room today, as I listened to the debate over how much students’ standardized assessments should play into teacher evaluation I couldn’t help feel that this how we are reacting to the discussion even on a personal level. Some of us are the bossy first graders announcing we know what the answer should and should not be. Some of us figure it will all play out in the end and we’re just along for the ride, while others look at this as a blank check to start some change.

And to empty the entire glue pot.

About Joanne


  1. SuperSub says:

    So I have to ask, which state eats the glue?


  1. […] This post was mentioned on Twitter by JoanneLeeJacobs. JoanneLeeJacobs said: New blog post: Tight goals, loose means http://bit.ly/bDVtFK […]

  2. […] In Federal, LA on July 6, 2010 at 4:09 pm As I was reading Joanne Jacobs’s blog today, I came across this tidbit from Organized Chaos. Its author, Ann Bailey-Lipsett, was invited to a […]