The degree gap

If You Thought the “Degree Gap” Was High Here, check out the female-male education gap in Canada, writes Carpe Diem. University of Alberta President Indira Samarasekera is under attack for saying that too few men are earning degrees.

“We’ll wake up in 20 years and we will not have the benefit of enough male talent,” said Samarasekera, a metallurgical engineer originally from Sri Lanka. “I’m going to be an advocate for young white men, because I can be,” she added, pointing to her Nixon-to-China status as a minority woman advocating for men.

The chart tells the story.

Better reading with DI and SFA

Direct Instruction and Success for All work best for students, writes John Wills Lloyd at Teach Effectively, citing a meta-analysis of 142 studies in the December 2009 issue of the Review of Educational Research.

Robert Slavin and colleagues reported that reading programs that provide extensive professional development on instructional strategies which promote student participation, strengthen phonics competence, and explicitly teach comprehension strategies are the best bets for improving reading achievement.

“Comprehensive programs such as DI and SFA should be at the core of coordinated, school-wide efforts to improve students’ outcomes,” Lloyd writes.

Teaching shouldn't be the 'worst job'

Teaching shouldn’t be the worst job on Earth, writes Elena Silva on The Quick and the Ed, responding to an Education Week commentary by Teach for America veteran  Kerry Kretchmar, who’s now working on a doctorate in teacher education.

Kretchmar starts out by recalling her first year teaching 32 kids in a rat-infested South Bronx basement. This is exactly the type of call-to-action that attracts young well-educated service-minded people to make a difference in the lives of poor children.

. . . the problem of public education – reforming teaching in particular – is not solved by describing the horrors of teaching in the worst schools, or by convincing individuals to join the cause. It will be solved by changing the conditions of one of the most complex occupations, and the largest public service workforce in the nation– most comparable in size to the U.S. military, so we don’t have to try so hard to convince and compel people to be great teachers.

A TFA first-grade teacher in Chicago finds an Onion parody — “Teach for America Chews Up, Spits Out Another Ethnic Studies Major” — is way too close to reality.

Every week I’m exhausted to a level of exhaustion that, before four months ago, I did not know existed.

And, yet, “the hardest job I could ever imagine” is “also incredibly rewarding. The feeling I get when my students learn something, or remember something I taught them, is priceless.”

Raising pay but allowing horrible working conditions will not persuade good people to stay in teaching.

Texas-centric history curriculum

The proposed social studies curriculum in Texas is all about Texas, all the time, complains Gary Nash, a UCLA professor and director of the National Center for History in Schools. From the El Paso Times:

Texas students “are going to know a great deal about their own state and it is a fine state, but they are going to know very little about the world and they are going to leave high school with a very myopic view of the history of humankind,” Nash said in an interview.

The state offers two years of Texas history, one year of world history and a yearlong look at contemporary world culture. In contrast, California teaches three years of world history and one year of state history.

The Board of Education’s new curriculum includes a list of historic figures that may be taught and those who must be taught. There’s no mention of Nicolaus Copernicus, Marie Curie and Pythagoras of Samos, Nash complains. Simon Bolivar, Albert Einstein and Isaac Newton also have been dropped. But teachers must teach students about their Texas state legislators.

Other critics say the curriculum doesn’t put enough stress on Hispanics, women, Native Americans and African-Americans. Of 160 people mentioned in the current draft, only 14 are Hispanic — and some of those are Spanish settlers.

State Rep. Norma Chávez, D-El Paso, told the board that Irma Rangel, the first Latina elected to the Texas Legislature, and Henry B. Gonzalez, the first Latino from Texas elected to Congress, should be moved from the may-be-taught to the must-be-taught list.

The board will hold public hearings in January.

Fifth-grade Santa is squelched

A fifth-grader in Muncie, Indiana took $10,331 from his grandparents’ safe and handed out $300 on the school bus before school officials stopped the giveaway.

Gym teacher vs. holocaust

The Holocaust never happened, according to a Las Vegas teacher.  P.E. teacher Lori Sublette, who has degrees in kinesiology, is assigned to a weekly “advocacy” class designed to “prepare students for life after high school.”  She would not discuss the incident with the Las Vegas Review-Journal.

However, Jewish students at  Northwest Career and Technical Academy say the teacher’s comments have sparked a wave of anti-Semitic jokes and threats. An anti-Jewish text message sent to multiple students that threatened to “slit your throats personally” is being investigated as a hate crime.

(Student Katie) Piranio said Sublette told students that history textbooks have inaccurate information and Holocaust photographs were doctored or distorted. She also said Sublette said in class that some Holocaust photographs were actually taken during an earlier time period in Russia.

After Piranio’s father complained to school officials, Sublette called him to apologize, but only for giving her “opinion” in class, Katie Piranio said.

The story inspired many viciously anti-Semitic comments, notes Gently Hew Stone.

Merry Christmas

And Happy Hanukkah, Swinging Solstice, Krazy Kwanzaa, Festive Festivus, etc.

Tutoring software that cares

Tutoring software that senses the student’s emotions is being tested by researchers, reports Education Week.

It’s not clear yet that sensitive software will produce better results, but one experiment by University of Massachusetts and Arizona State researchers boosted the pass rate on state geometry tests by 10 percent.

The system picks up on students’ emotional states through hundreds of sensors embedded in the computer, students’ chairs, and other aspects of the students’ learning environment.

Sensors worn like a bracelet around the wrist detect changes in students’ pulse and in moisture levels on the surface of the skin. Sensors embedded in the chair cushions identify nine different postures a learner might take. Leaning forward, for example, suggests engagement, while a student leaning to the side might be bored or frustrated. On the computer mouse, pressure-sensitive sensors signal whether a student is squeezing harder in possible frustration.

The researchers also collect data on students’ emotions through a video camera embedded on the computer. It trains its focus on the student’s eyebrows, mouth, and nose, discerning whether the learner is smiling, frowning, or yawning.

The tutor can identify changes in students’ moods more than half the time, researchers say.  Animated tutors “mirror those emotions and offer an appropriate response,” emphasizing the importance of effort.

What the researchers have found in some of the studies so far is that the emotion-sensitive tutors, besides boosting students’ average achievement, seem to lead to improvements in the way that students think about math and their own math abilities. They are more likely after their tutoring sessions to agree, for instance, with statements saying “mathematics is an important topic” and to believe they are good at it. Students also seem to get bored with the tutor less quickly than they do with the unenhanced system.

The emotion-sensing tutor worked best for girls, low achievers and special-education students.

Boy arrested for angry football throw

When a 14-year-old boy “angrily” threw a football at another boy’s leg, middle school officials called the police, who arrested the boy for assault. The other boy was not injured. From the Mountain View (CA) Voice:

There was no real explanation as to why the incident was considered serious enough to involve police. The police report states that the unnamed juvenile suspect appeared “angry.”

There must be a back story here, but it’s hard to imagine what would justify calling the police and giving this boy a police record.

In Boston, a single mother called the police to get her 14-year-old son to stop playing Grand Theft Auto and go to sleep. The police persuaded him to obey his mother without arresting him.

Training the 21-year-old teacher

Bright students at University of Maine-Fort Kent will be able to earn a three-year bachelor’s degree in education, reports the Bangor Daily News.

Student Teachers Aspiring to meet the Real challenges of Schools (STARS) includes the same coursework as the four-year degree; students will earn more credits per semester, take summer classes and use AP credits.

Teacher Quality Bulletin thinks 21 is very young to be a teacher.