‘Tested’ on Britannica

I’m doing some writing on Britannica Blog, starting with a post on Linda Perlstein’s excellent new book, Tested.

What does it mean to “teach to the test”? Linda Perlstein’s new book, Tested: One American School Struggles to Make the Grade, goes inside the classroom at Tyler Heights, an Annapolis, Maryland, elementary school that’s working relentlessly to boost the test scores of its low-income black and Hispanic students.

Children practice endlessly writing one-paragraph answers, known as BCR’s (”basic constructed responses’’), that they’ll use to show reading comprehension on the Maryland School Assessment (MSA). A third-grade teacher models a BCR:

Damon and Pythias is a play because it has the elements of a play. Some elements of a play are that plays have stage directions. Also, there is a narrator. This play also has a lot of characters. So I know this play has all the features it needs.

The words and phrases in bold above are transitions and MSA vocabulary likely to earn a higher score: Students are taught these are “million-dollar words,” and they enjoy adding up their earnings per paragraph.

Students have little time to write anything but BCRs: They may write about plays but they don’t act them out, much less try to write their own. They don’t read chapter books and rarely go beyond the literal interpretation of what they’ve read.

Furthermore (a million-dollar word!), what’s not on the test isn’t taught: The minimum of four hours a day devoted to reading and math squeezes social studies and science out of the curriculum. (To make more time for reading and math, 44 percent of elementary schools spend less time on science, social studies and other untested subjects, reports The Center on Education Policy.) Only in the last few months of the school year, after the MSA is given in March, do students work on social studies projects, do science experiments, go on field trips or perform in talent shows.

But in pre-NCLB (No Child Left Behind) days, Tyler Heights students weren’t critical thinkers and creative writers: Only 17 percent passed the MSA in 2000. Many went on to fail in middle school and drop out of high school.

Principal Tina McKnight, a fanatically hard-working woman, started the turnaround in 2000. Superintendent Eric Smith brought in Saxon Math and Open Court, a phonics-first reading curriculum that tells teachers — often inexperienced — exactly what to say.

Because it has so many poor students, Tyler Heights gets extra funding to pay for very small classes and a variety of pullout programs for students who aren’t doing well. Half the third-grade class receives some kind of special help.

The school also can afford consultants who promise to help students tackle the test. Before a practice MSA, students do a sort of self-massage and stretching exercise to “activate” their brains. Teachers hand out peppermints, which are supposed to help students calm and relax themselves.

Students are rewarded with snacks and “Scholar Dollars,” redeemable for trinkets, for everything they do right, till the principal and teachers worry the kids have lost all sense that good behavior should be the norm or that knowledge is worth having for its own sake.

When the book starts, Tyler Heights has posted its first year of good test scores. McKnight and her teachers worry it’s a fluke. By the conclusion, the school has done slightly better: 87.4 percent of third, fourth and fifth graders test proficient in reading, 80 percent in math. The third graders, who’d entered far behind, hit 90 percent in both categories.

Some read this book as an indictment of NCLB’s push for accountability. I see Tested as an intelligent look at a complex problem. Yes, Tyler Heights has gone test crazy. But without the push to raise scores, where would the students be?

I’ve seen what happens to students who drift through elementary school without mastering the basics. My book, Our School: The Inspiring Story of Two Teachers, One Big Idea and the Charter School That Beat the Odds, is the story of Downtown College Prep, a charter high school in San Jose that pushes, shoves and nags its mostly Mexican-American students on to the college track. Students start ninth grade with fifth- or sixth-grade reading and math skills. They are crippled academically unless they’re forced to go back and learn what they should have learned the first time.

Buoyed — and amazed — by their students’ success, Tyler Heights’ third-grade teachers plan to broaden their instruction for the following year. Rather than require all students to read the same stories, they will divide students by reading ability, give them books at their reading level and discuss the reading in small groups. They plan to incorporate social studies and science in reading, do real writing, bring in the “gifted” teacher to work on critical thinking and rewrite Open Court tests to match MSA skills so students can take fewer tests.

The school Perlstein describes is not one that middle-class parents would choose for their children. But Tyler Heights is growing into a good school for its very needy students.

About Joanne


  1. Tested came in the mail the other day – I’m working on a review of it as well.

    I haven’t finished the book, but I interpret it so far along similar lines. While you present the real issue – the effects of accountability measures – as being either “Are we hampered by these restrictions?” or “Where would we be without them?” I don’t feel that Perlstein is comfortable with letting us make that decision. My review will most likely reflect that.

  2. While I think teaching to the test is perfectly okay, it doesn’t really appear that they are teaching *reading* to kids who can’t read. Have the kids been tested on a separate test to be sure that they actually have comprehension?

  3. But what about the teachers’ creativity? It’s being stifled!

    (Yes, that’s sarcasm)