Edwards’ integration plan

Aaron Hanscom, who teaches at an all-minority elementary school in Watts (OK, there’s one white kid), wonders why John Edwards wants to spend $100 million to get poor kids enrolled at middle-class schools and middle-class kids lured to inner-city magnet schools but not one cent on charters or vouchers.

Say Anything also thinks low-income parents would benefit from getting a voucher they could spend at a private school, charter or suburban public school.

A commenter points out that a judge ordered $2 billion in extra spending to integrate Kansas City schools. It paid for lavish facilities and special programs in the inner city.

The money bought higher teachers’ salaries, 15 new schools, and such amenities as an Olympic-sized swimming pool with an underwater viewing room, television and animation studios, a robotics lab, a 25-acre wildlife sanctuary, a zoo, a model United Nations with simultaneous translation capability, and field trips to Mexico and Senegal. The student-teacher ratio was 12 or 13 to 1, the lowest of any major school district in the country.

Achievement didn’t improve. Neither did integration.

Eventually, the program was abandoned. The expanded bureaucracy remains, writes Joe Miller in Cross X.

While some low-income students would benefit from attending predominantly middle-class schools, I think the most disadvantaged do best in small schools designed to meet their needs, such as the charter school I write about in Our School. The best educational program for the children of educated parents often isn’t necessarily the most effective for children whose parents can’t do much to supplement and support their education at home.

Update: Liam Julian suggests devoting money and energy to improving all schools (and providing choice) rather than busing kids hither and yon.

Illiteracy kills

Elderly people who read poorly die earlier than good readers, concludes a study in the Archives of Internal Medicine.

Older adults who cannot read and understand basic health information have a 50 per cent higher mortality rate over a five-year period than those with adequate reading skills, the study found.

. . . “When patients can’t read, they are not able to do the things necessary to stay healthy,” (Dr. David) Baker noted. “They don’t know how to take their medications correctly, they don’t understand when to seek medical care, and they don’t know how to care for their diseases.”

Researchers looked at retirees’ race/ethnicity, education, income, health behaviors (smoking, alcohol consumption, exercise) and chronic medical conditions (diabetes, asthma, heart disease, etc.). About one in four had trouble reading text and “doctor appointment slips, hospital forms and pill bottles that required understanding numbers.”

Low health literacy was the top predictor of mortality after smoking, also surpassing income and years of education, the study showed.

Of course, it’s possible that reading problems are a symptom rather than a cause of declining health.

To keep mentally sharp in old age, build your “cognitive reserve.”

Cheaters’ prep

Already accused of cheating on the state exam for two years in a row, an Oakland charter school also appears to have changed transcripts to qualify students for college. The San Francisco Chronicle has documents for five students.

In spring 2006, teachers’ records for an 11th-grade boy at University Preparatory Charter Academy in East Oakland showed an F and five D’s.

His report card for the same period featured three D’s and three C’s.

His transcript — the one received by the California State University campuses that accepted him — glowed with three A’s and three B’s.

A teacher at the school e-mailed me months ago to ask my advice on how to inform the hands-off board what was going on. Finally, eight former teachers blew the whistle, blaming Principal Isaac Haqq, the school’s founder, for altering grades, misnaming courses and blocking low-scoring students from taking state exams.

The 11th-grader’s records for spring 2006 show that his grade-point average jumped from 1.55 on his report card to 2.93 on his college transcript.

Besides the grade changes, his records also reveal morphed course names. What is called “math” on the teachers’ records becomes “math analysis” on the boy’s report card, and “trigonometry” on his college transcript.

“English” is changed to “English Literature” on the report card and “English 3″ on the transcript. “History” transforms to “World Civilization” and then to “U.S. History.”

Of the school’s 475 students, 279 are on independent study; they don’t attend classes. Teachers charge low scorers are dumped into independent study, which doesn’t cost the school much, and listed as 12th graders, which means they’re exempt from state testing. In fall 2006, 365 of the school’s 475 students were listed as 12th graders; only 100 seniors graduated in June and 40 went on to college.

Some graduates who got into elite colleges praise Haqq’s dedication. Teachers say he focused on the best students and set the rest up for failure.

Principal Haqq, who has a history of “breaking the rules,” as the Chronicle put it, has resigned. The school is likely to lose its charter in August, barring a miraculous turnaround.

Immigrant kids prefer English

Immigrant parents “struggle to keep their children bilingual,” reports the Boston Globe. Even if the parents speak their native language at home, children respond in English.

Rubén G. Rumbaut, a sociologist at the University of California at Irvine, and his team of researchers looked at 5,700 adults in their 20s and 30s in Southern California from different generations to see how long their language survived. A key finding centered on 1,900 American-born children of immigrants. The shift toward English among them was swift: While 87 percent grew up speaking another language at home, only 34 percent said they spoke it well by adulthood. And nearly 70 percent said they preferred to speak English.

“English wins, and it does so in short order,” said Rumbaut, who presented his findings to the US House Judiciary subcommittee on immigration in May.

It’s easiest to retain Spanish. Sixty percent of Mexican-Americans raised in Spanish-speaking families say they speak Spanish well in early adulthood; half prefer English. By the third generation, 10 percent are fluent in Spanish and all prefer English.

U.S.-born children of Chinese, Korean, and Vietnamese immigrants lose their parents’ language more quickly; less than 25 percent say they’re fluent as young adults.

I have a hard time seeing this as a problem of the school system. Parents can teach their children at home or get together with others to start Saturday language schools, like the Chinese immigrant parents in Silicon Valley. Young adults who realize fluency in their parents’ language would be a career asset can build on their base knowledge, however neglected. Most don’t need to speak two languages well. They do need to be fluent and literate in English.

Criminalizing seventh-grade pests

Schoolboy pranks may be treated as felony sex offenses, reports the Portland Oregonian.

The two boys tore down the hall of Patton Middle School after lunch, swatting the bottoms of girls as they ran — what some kids later said was a common form of greeting.

But bottom-slapping is against policy in McMinnville Public Schools. So a teacher’s aide sent the gawky seventh-graders to the office, where the vice principal and a police officer stationed at the school soon interrogated them.

After hours of interviews with students the day of the February incident, the officer read the boys their Miranda rights and hauled them off in handcuffs to juvenile jail, where they spent the next five days.

Now, Cory Mashburn and Ryan Cornelison, both 13, face the prospect of 10 years in juvenile detention and a lifetime on the sex offender registry in a case that poses a fundamental question: When is horseplay a crime?

Even juvenile sex offenders who commit real offenses usually don’t pose a threat when they grow up, writes Maggie Jones in New York Times Magazine. Ninety percent will not become adult sex offenders. But they may be on sex offender registries for life.

Teacher in health class

In pursuit of higher certification, TMAO of Teaching in the 408 took an all-day health class for teachers. He live-blogged the class in the guise of taking notes, though worried there wouldn’t be enough content to justify taking fake notes.

8:54 I walk in. Where’s the agenda? Where are the objectives?

He survives yoga and declines to join a discussion of spiritual health.

11:15 I learn that violence, which is unavoidable, is a major health issue.

11:16 I learn the war, which is horrible, is a major health issue.

He returns from lunch feeling distinctly unhealthy but decides it’s coincidence rather than irony.

3:02 Group work ends. My group is assigned meth. We’re supposed to present for 20 minutes. We’re supposed to be creative. We’re supposed to have hand-outs. My group decides to play a game called “Name That Addict.” This is not my idea. I go to the bathroom twice.

The day ends at 4:45.

Studying at the airport

It’s exam time in the desperately poor nation of Guinea, so Gbessia International Airport is crowded with students who come each to study by the airport floodlights. The Guardian reports:

Groups begin heading to the airport at dusk, hoping to reserve a coveted spot under the oval light cast by one of a dozen lampposts in the parking lot. Some come from over an hour’s walk away.

“I used to study by candlelight at home but that hurt my eyes. So I prefer to come here. We’re used to it,” said 18-year-old Mohamed Sharif, who sat under the fluorescent beam reviewing notes on Mongolia for the geography portion of his university entrance exam.

Only about a fifth of Guinea’s 10 million people have access to electricity. Those who do experience frequent power cuts.

. . . “My parents don’t worry about me because they know I’m here to seek my future,” said Ali Mara, 10, busy studying a diagram of an insect’s cephalothorax.

They sit by age group with seven-to-nine-year-olds on a curb in a traffic island and teenagers on the concrete pilings flanking the national and international terminals. Few cars disturb their studies.

Those who live too far to get to the airport study at gas stations or sit outside the homes of families who can afford a generator, “picking up the crumbs of light falling from their illuminated living rooms.”

Ruled by a dictator for 23 years, Guinea has rivers that could provide hydroelectric power; the country also is rich in minerals.

Via Nothing To Do With Arbroath.

On the bubble

“Bubble” students — those who are close to proficiency — benefit the most from No Child Left Behind, concludes a Chicago study. Researchers found low achievers scored “the same or lower” under NCLB compared to Chicago’s pre-NCLB accountability system; for gifted students, researchers found “mixed evidence of gains” in the NCLB era. Education Week reports:

Kids in the middle — the ones closest to proficiency — performed better under NCLB than they did before.

This study lends credence to common critiques of that law encourages teachers to focus on the so-called bubble kids — the ones that are close to reaching proficiency.

Growth models can fix the problem by rewarding schools for progress of students’ at the lowest end of the spectrum. But this study brings to mind the question about gifted students. What incentives will schools have to reach out to gifted students if the ultimate goal of NCLB is proficiency for all by 2013-14?

At Parentalcation, Rory argues for spending more on raising the achievement of the middle third of students.

Matt Johntson argues for focusing on the bottom third on Going to the Mat.

Both say gifted students don’t need extra resources to excel. They’ve got pushy parents or inner drive to keep them on track.

The whale gap

Some 84 percent of elementary education funding goes to teaching children about whales, reports The Onion. A panel of experts asks: Is that enough?

Get a day job

The choice for young Americans is not selling out to evil corporations or “starving as an unpaid or underpaid activist,” writes Eric at Classical Values. Get a day job while you’re waiting for your big break. Join the working class.

In response to two books on the job market’s indifference to film and women’s studies majors, Eric praises Molly Hartmann Ahrens, a Bryn Mawr sociology graduate who found an income and satisfaction as a bartender. Now she gets paid — plus tips! — for observing social interactions.

He blames “the relentless, all-encompassing self esteem movement” for creating an entitlement mindset.

Even people who might have practical degrees in something useful nonetheless think it is beneath them or degrading to have to work in entry level positions and work their way up.

Another head of the monster is the creation of a useless and unemployable caste, by the conferring of meaningless degrees in an unending litany of identity group “studies.” The holders of these degrees have their self esteem delusionally bolstered by a false belief that the “system” which sees no value in their valueless degrees is victimizing them . . .

No wonder they feel entitled. If they didn’t have the feeling of entitlement, I’m afraid they’d have nothing at all.

He suggests grads who majored in “me studies” consider training in bartending, automotive repair and handyman skills.

When my daughter was graduated from Stanford with a degree in American Studies, she found employers were eager to hire her — as an unpaid intern. She lowered her sights a notch, found a paying (not very well) job, worked for awhile and then started law school. (I visited her this week in Chicago, where she’s working for the summer in the U.S. attorney’s office, and heard “Richie the Rat” testify in the “Family Secrets” trial of elderly gangsters.) If young people have a sense of entitlement, it doesn’t last long once they hit the job market. You take what you can get or move back in with your parents.