Grief vultures

The Virginia Tech campus has been flooded with self-appointed grief counselors, therapy dogs and Scientologists, reports the Washington Post. There’s something vulturish about it.

BTW, if anyone has advice on how to gets comments working again, let me know. I can’t post comments for you; they don’t work for me either.

Update: Trying to make sense of the senseless slaughter at Virginia Tech, leads to mawkishness, false sentiment and vulturism, writes Christopher Hitchens on Slate. Cornell’s president ordered bells run 33 times for the victims and their killer.

For an academic president to have equated 32 of his fellow humans with their murderer in an orgy of “one-ness” was probably the stupidest thing that happened last week, but not by a very wide margin.

Read the whole thing.

Today’s the day

I’m speaking today at 4:30 in the Sandia room at the National Charter Schools Conference at the Albuquerque Convention Center. The schedule at a glance lists another presentation in Sandia along with mine, “Ride the Carrot Salad: Preparing Latino Students for College.” Rest assured, the room is mine!

I’ll have copies of Our School for sale and signing.

By the way, I think my comments are on the fritz. I tried to comment on this post and got an error message and I’m being asked to “moderate” comments that don’t exist. It’s hard to deal with this on the road, but I’ll see what I can do.

Carnival of Education

This week’s Carnival of Education, hosted by The Ed Wonks, features a provocative post by Miss Profe, who complains that U.S. student don’t take responsibility for their own learning.

At my current place of employ, there is a lot of talk re: self-advocacy and the power to change one’s world, but not nearly as much talk re:owning the learning process. This is a carry-over from the lack of responsibility many students have in their lives outside of school. They wait for things to be done to them and for them, rather than thinking, “What can I do for myself?”

Teachers and parents are a big part of the problem. How many times have teachers given students study guides and/or outlines for tests? How often do teachers establish checkpoints for major projects? How often do teachers give “extra credit”, accept homework that’s more than a week old, or give the opportunity to re-take a test or a quiz, sometimes multiple times? How many times have the parents of our students brought or faxed homework to school that their children “forgot.”

French students don’t expect this much hand-holding, Miss Profe says.

When my daughter was an SAT tutor, she had students who thought they were putting one over on her if they didn’t do the work. Her view was, “It’s your choice. I get paid whether you do well or not.”

Fingerprinting volunteers

Because she refuses to be fingerprinted, “Criminal Mom” of Daft Musings no longer volunteers at her child’s school.

I don’t know what’s going on in Neil’s classroom, because I’m not there every week, as I used to be in his classes, and the teacher snippily dismisses my concerns. I’ve actually had to buy materials to teach him math at his level myself. Peter helped coach Neil’s robotics team until the principal insisted all coaches be fingerprinted, whereupon Peter bailed. I no longer go to HIPS meetings, I don’t even volunteer for events where fingerprinting is not required, and when asked to contribute financially or materially for a fund-raising drive, I give far less than I once used to.

Some parents acquiesced to the policy: to add to what I consider a humiliation, they now also have to wear picture ID badges whenever they volunteer on campus. From where I stand, I can’t really tell if there has been a drop-off in volunteering, but a parent told my husband the difference is precipitous.

I wrote about this last year. Great way to keep parents away from the school.

The percentage game

Getting into a good college isn’t Admission Impossible?, writes Kevin Carey on American Prospect. Top colleges are admitting a lower percentage of applicants because more students are applying to many more colleges.

The stock characters include the tearful student — dreams crushed under an avalanche of rejection letters — the angry parent, the frenzied guidance counselor, and the college admissions official or other expert who notes with grateful wonder, “If I had to apply to my alma mater today, I couldn’t get in.”

There’s just one problem: it’s not true. The declining odds of getting into an elite college are mostly a statistical mirage, caused by confusion between college applicants and college applications.

More students are graduating from high school and applying to college, but “the number of spaces in elite colleges is increasing too, at a nearly identical rate.” What’s soaring is the number of applications to elite schools.

Imagine 20 students, each of whom applies to five schools and gets into two. Now imagine if the same students each applied to ten schools and got into two. The outcome for the students is the same: two acceptance letters. But the schools report lower admission rates, and the odds of admission seem worse.

I was graduated from high school in 1970. I applied to five colleges and got into two, which was one more than I needed. My daughter, class of ’99, applied to 10 schools and got into four.

Via Eduwonk.

See you in Albuquerque

For those of you going to the National Charter Schools Conference in Albuquerque. don’t forget to come by tomorrow, April 25, at 4:30 for my presentation, “Ride the Carrot Salad: Preparing Latino Students for College.” Jennifer Andaluz, executive director of Downtown College Prep, the charter school in my book, Our School, will be the co-presenter. I’ll have copies of Our School for sale and signing.

Bee at the Carnival of Homeschooling

This week’s Carnival of Homeschooling has a bee theme and is hosted by Sprittibee. Bee there.

Writing to kill

Gory stories are a staple in college creative writing classes. What should an instructor do if she suspects a student might act on his fantasies? From Salon:

Creative writing teachers have long wrestled with what they should do with students who turn in gruesome stories, as many colleges do not have formal policies about how teachers should respond. Further, there are no set rules for determining whether a story is the product of a febrile artistic imagination or a potentially violent criminal. Or both.

“Lots of great literary works are deep and dark and disturbing — that would be Kafka,” says Deborah Landau, director of the creative writing program at New York University, who plans to discuss university protocol with her staff in the wake of Monday’s massacre. Yet teachers increasingly are being expected to distinguish between students’ pushing their creative boundaries or showing frightening warning signs. That’s a tall task, especially when students routinely hand in twisted texts dripping with bloodshed, cruelty, perversion and extreme sex scenes, say teachers.

Most of these horror writers aren’t Kafka. But very few are would-be killers either.

I majored in creative writing in the early ’70s. I don’t recall this phenomenon at all. No violence, no explicit sex. Of course, my memory’s going.

Bang, you’re fired

To argue that an armed student could have stopped the Virginia Tech killer, an adjunct professor at Boston’s Emmanuel College pointed a Magic Marker at students in his class and said, “Bang” several times. A student he’d prepared earlier “shot” Nicholas Winset, a financial accounting instructor, with an imaginary gun.

“Why did I stop?” Winset asked his 23 undergraduate students , before someone replied that the “gunman” was shot.

“So guns maybe aren’t all bad,” Winset told the group.

He was fired — two weeks before the end of the semester — and barred from campus. The administration’s statement says the school prohibits “any behavior or action which makes light of or mimics the terrible tragedy at Virginia Tech.”

Winset said the Catholic college urged instructors to discuss the tragedy with students. He spent five minutes discussing victimhood, nonviolence and gun control before moving on to accounting.

Emmanuel accuses the professor of incivility.

The college said on Monday that Winset’s firing “had nothing to do with academic freedom” but rather “his insensitivity toward the students who were murdered at Virginia Tech” and “his use of obscene and discriminatory language which is not tolerated from students, faculty or staff at this institution.”

Winset was “disparaging the victims as rich white kids combined with an obscene epithet. He did not do this as part of an open debate with his students,” the statement said.

This must be the first time in modern history that someone on a college campus got in trouble for referring to rich white people.

The only student interviewed said he didn’t think his classmates were upset or offended, but someone must have said something to someone.

Winset had told Emmanuel before the incident that he was moving on to another job, but apparently they couldn’t tolerate him on campus for the final two weeks. What’s open debate going to sound like at Emmanuel in the future? Kind of quiet.

Winset has posted a defense on YouTube.

Classically Liberal provides several examples of school (and mall) killers who were stopped by armed resistance.

‘Our School’ in New Mexico

I’m heading to Albuqerque for the National Charter Schools Conference. I’ll be talking on Wednesday, April 25 at 4:30 on “Ride the Carrot Salad: Preparing Latino Students for College.” Jennifer Andaluz, executive director of Downtown College Prep, the charter school in my book, Our School, will be the co-presenter. I plan to make her do most of the work.

If you’re going to be at the convention, come on by. Of course, I’ll have copies of Our School for sale and signing.