Creationism as paganism

Creationism is “a kind of paganism,” says the Vatican’s astronomer, Brother Guy Consolmagno, speaking in Scotland.

“Religion needs science to keep it away from superstition and keep it close to reality, to protect it from creationism, which at the end of the day is a kind of paganism – it’s turning God into a nature god. And science needs religion in order to have a conscience, to know that, just because something is possible, it may not be a good thing to do.”

Brother Consolmagno also called papal infallibility a “PR disaster.”

What it actually meant was that, on matters of faith, followers should accept “somebody has got to be the boss, the final authority.”

“It’s not like he has a magic power, that God whispers the truth in his ear,” he said.

They don’t make ’em like they used to in the Vatican, I guess.

About Joanne

Comments

  1. Br. Guy is also a fascinating speaker, is the Vatican’s meteoriticist (and has travelled to the Antarctic ice cap to search for meteorites) and is co-author of Turn Left At Orion.

    If anybody knows the difference between science and religiously-motivated pseudo-science, he does.

  2. I was taught by Catholic priests 25 years ago who said roughly the same thing then. Nothing new here.

  3. Unfortunately, some of those who need to hear what Br. Guy has to say (on creationism in particular) won’t listen, because they are people who regard *Catholicism* as a form of paganism.

    (If I were putting together an ethics-in-science-and-teaching panel, I think Br. Guy would be one of the first people I called up. I hadn’t heard of him before but from these two quotations I think he’s someone who knows his stuff)

    One of my friends in grad school had done his master’s work with a botanist who was also a Jesuit priest. He said that the priest used to enjoy arguing Scripture with students who came to him and wanted to tell him he was going to Hell because he taught evolution. (Usually they did not know of his background; he didn’t wear a clerical collar or any other type of “marking” in class)

  4. Jeff_H says:

    I wish I could remember whose quote this is but I read this one time and it stuck with me.

    “The Bible tells us how to go to heaven, it does not tell us how the heavens go.”

  5. Wayne Martin says:

    > “The Bible tells us how to go to heaven,
    > it does not tell us how the heavens go.”

    Google kicks out a number of sites that attribute this statement to Galileo.

  6. Jeff_H says:

    “I slap the side of my head and say DUH”

    Of course now I remember, Thanks Wayne

  7. Actually, what Guy (who used to be an MIT Science Fiction Society keyholder and once went to a Passover Seder with me) says about Creationism isn’t nearly as bad as he could: consider that creationsim assumes that God created the world in 4004 BC with all the light from galaxies billions of light years away, the rate of radioactive devay in the soil, the various strata showing the trilobites and dinosaurs etc, already in place. Creationsim proposes God the Liar.

  8. Wayne Martin says:

    > creationsim assumes that God created the
    > world in 4004 BC with all the light
    > from galaxies billions of light years away,
    > the rate of radioactive devay in the soil,
    > the various strata showing the trilobites
    > and dinosaurs etc, already in place.
    > Creationsim proposes God the Liar.

    Not exactly. This 4004 BC date comes from Irish Churhman and Scholar James Ussher:


    htmhttp://www.lhup.edu/~dsimanek/ussher.htm

    James Ussher (1581-1656), Archbishop of Armagh, Primate of All Ireland, and Vice-Chancellor of Trinity College in Dublin was highly regarded in his day as a churchman and as a scholar. Of his many works, his treatise on chronology has proved the most durable. Based on an intricate correlation of Middle Eastern and Mediterranean histories and Holy writ, it was incorporated into an authorized version of the Bible printed in 1701, and thus came to be regarded with almost as much unquestioning reverence as the Bible itself. Having established the first day of creation as Sunday 23 October 4004 BC, by the arguments set forth in the passage below, Ussher calculated the dates of other biblical events, concluding, for example, that Adam and Eve were driven from Paradise on Monday 10 November 4004 BC, and that the ark touched down on Mt Ararat on 5 May 2348 BC `on a Wednesday’.

    As to the bit about radioactive decay and dinosaurs, creationists do some fancy footwork here, suggesting that these phenomena were implanted by the deity at creation to “test man’s faith”.

  9. greeneyeshade says:

    Wayne Martin’s line about ‘testing man’s faith’ isn’t that different from Bigger’s ‘God the Liar.’ My Presbyterian-turned-high-Anglican boss once compared that theory to building a new house and building banged-up “old” furniture at the same time to put in the attic.

  10. AndyJoy says:

    Interesting–evidently creationists come in more varieties than I realized. I’m one myself, but I’ve never heard the “God created the earth with fossils in place” theory before.

  11. Wayne Martin says:

    I doubt that there is any monolithic school-of-thought about creationism, but the point about “testing man’s faith” pops up in discussion from time-to-time. Most likely the point has been pressed pressed by fundamentalist “preachers” to their congregations:


    http://www.skepticfiles.org/evo2/vistaedt.htm

    [The following appeared on the LA Times Opinion page directly under Phillip Johnson’s editorial about creationism. Due to an overwhelming
    number of requests, I am reproducing the following without permission.]

    THE BIBLE IS NOT A SCIENCE TEXTBOOK
    By Michael Gotlieb

    There are some who believe that when God created the world, He also created fossils in order to test man’s faith in Scripture. Those same
    people believe that the universe literally was created in six days.

    [Michael Gotlieb is the rabbi at Temple Judea in Vista, CA.]
    —-

    In the last twenty years or so, there have been concerted efforts to challenge the validity of the results of geochronolgy, which uses radio-isotopes for the age determinations.


    Geochronology:
    http://www.asa3.org/ASA/resources/Wiens.html
    http://www.trueorigin.org/dating.asp
    http://www.creationtheory.org/YoungEarth/Hartman-2.shtml
    http://www.talkorigins.org/indexcc/CF/CF210.html

    Radioisotopic Geochronology has withstood its challenges handily. I happen to like the “testing man’s faith” argument a lot, as it’s very difficult to argue against within the framework of religion.

  12. Anthony says:

    AndyJoy – I’ve heard two stories about fossils from creationists: one, they’re the remains of animals which died in The Flood, the other, that they were placed there by God for some reason or other at the creation. Given that fossils occur in strata which have tilted, it’s rather difficult to justify them ending up there after the flood. Unless the earth wrinkled as it dried out?

    I’ve also heard a creationist propose, with a straight face, that God changed the speed of light from infinite to finite at the end of the flood, so that there could be a rainbow. God created rainbows after the flood, you see.

  13. http://bellab.web.fc2.com/
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index1.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index2.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index3.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index4.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index5.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index6.html

    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index7.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index8.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index9.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index10.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index11.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index12.html

    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index13.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index14.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index15.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index16.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index17.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index18.html

    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index19.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index20.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index21.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index22.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index23.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index24.html

    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index25.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index26.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index27.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index28.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index29.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index30.html

    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index31.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index32.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index33.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index34.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index35.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index36.html

    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index37.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index38.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index39.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index40.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index41.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index42.html

    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index43.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index44.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index45.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index46.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index47.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index48.html

    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index49.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index50.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index51.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index52.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index53.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index54.html

    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index55.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index56.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index57.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index58.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index59.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index60.html

    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index61.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index62.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index63.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index64.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index65.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index66.html

    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index67.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index68.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index69.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index70.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index71.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index72.html

    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index73.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index74.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index75.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index76.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index77.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index78.html

    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index79.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index80.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index81.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index82.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index83.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index84.html

    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index85.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index86.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index87.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index88.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index89.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index90.html

    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index91.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index92.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index93.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index94.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index95.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index96.html

    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index97.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index98.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index99.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index100.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index101.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index102.html

    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index103.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index104.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index105.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index106.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index107.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index108.html

    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index109.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index110.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index111.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index112.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index113.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index114.html

    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index115.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index116.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index117.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index118.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index119.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index120.html

    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index121.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index122.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index123.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index124.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index125.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index126.html

    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index127.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index128.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index129.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index130.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index131.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index132.html

    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index133.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index134.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index135.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index136.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index137.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index138.html

    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index139.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index140.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index141.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index142.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index143.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index144.html

    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index145.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index146.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index147.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index148.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index149.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index150.html

    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index151.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index152.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index153.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index154.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index155.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index156.html

    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index157.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index158.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index159.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index160.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index161.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index162.html

    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index163.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index164.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index165.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index166.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index167.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index168.html

    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index169.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index170.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index171.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index172.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index173.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index174.html

    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index175.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index176.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index177.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index178.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index179.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index180.html

    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index181.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index182.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index183.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index184.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index185.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index186.html

    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index187.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index188.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index189.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index190.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index191.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index192.html

    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index193.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index194.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index195.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index196.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index197.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index198.html

    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index199.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index200.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index201.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index202.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index203.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index204.html

    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index205.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index206.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index207.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index208.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index209.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index210.html

    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index211.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index212.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index213.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index214.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index215.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index216.html

    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index217.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index218.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index219.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index220.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index221.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index222.html

    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index223.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index224.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index225.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index226.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index227.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index228.html

    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index229.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index230.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index231.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index232.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index233.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index234.html

    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index235.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index236.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index237.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index238.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index239.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index240.html

    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index241.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index242.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index243.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index244.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index245.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index246.html

    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index247.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index248.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index249.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index250.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index251.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index252.html

    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index253.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index254.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index255.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index256.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index257.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index258.html

    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index259.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index260.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index261.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index262.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index263.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index264.html

    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index265.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index266.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index267.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index268.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index269.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index270.html

    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index271.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index272.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index273.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index274.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index275.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index276.html

    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index277.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index278.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index279.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index280.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index281.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index282.html

    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index283.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index284.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index285.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index286.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index287.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index288.html

    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index289.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index290.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index291.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index292.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index293.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index294.html

    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index295.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index296.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index297.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index298.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index299.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index300.html

    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index301.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index302.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index303.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index304.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index305.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index306.html

    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index307.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index308.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index309.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index310.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index311.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index312.html

    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index313.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index314.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index315.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index316.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index317.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index318.html

    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index319.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index320.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index321.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index322.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index323.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index324.html

    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index325.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index326.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index327.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index328.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index329.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index330.html

    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index331.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index332.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index333.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index334.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index335.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index336.html

    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index337.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index338.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index339.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index340.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index341.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index342.html

    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index343.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index344.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index345.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index346.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index347.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index348.html

    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index349.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index350.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index351.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index352.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index353.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index354.html

    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index355.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index356.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index357.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index358.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index359.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index360.html

    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index361.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index362.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index363.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index364.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index365.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index366.html

    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index367.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index368.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index369.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index370.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index371.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index372.html

    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index373.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index374.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index375.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index376.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index377.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index378.html

    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index379.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index380.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index381.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index382.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index383.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index384.html

    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index385.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index386.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index387.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index388.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index389.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index390.html

    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index391.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index392.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index393.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index394.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index395.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index396.html

    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index397.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index398.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index399.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index400.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index401.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index402.html

    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index403.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index404.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index405.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index406.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index407.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index408.html

    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index409.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index410.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index411.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index412.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index413.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index414.html

    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index415.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index416.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index417.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index418.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index419.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index420.html

    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index421.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index422.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index423.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index424.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index425.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index426.html

    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index427.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index428.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index429.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index430.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index431.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index432.html

    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index433.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index434.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index435.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index436.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index437.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index438.html

    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index439.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index440.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index441.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index442.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index443.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index444.html

    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index445.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index446.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index447.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index448.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index449.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index450.html

    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index451.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index452.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index453.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index454.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index455.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index456.html

    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index457.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index458.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index459.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index460.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index461.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index462.html

    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index463.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index464.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index465.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index466.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index467.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index468.html

    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index469.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index470.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index471.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index472.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index473.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index474.html

    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index475.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index476.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index477.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index478.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index479.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index480.html

    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index481.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index482.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index483.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index484.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index485.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index486.html

    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index487.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index488.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index489.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index490.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index491.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index492.html

    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index493.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index494.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index495.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index496.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index497.html
    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index498.html

    http://bellab.web.fc2.com/index499.html